Cloud cost: capital expenditure and operating expenditure

Owning servers is capital expenditure (CapEx). Renting them is operational expenditure (OpEx).

A hardware seller's site lists a physical server for ₱180,000, and a cloud console lists a 2 GB server at ₱3 per hour. A student team building a project app presses Create on the hourly server. Its bill grows only while the server runs.

Buy a physical serverPaid once, up front
Rent a cloud serverPaid by the hour
Think first. The university's enlistment system needs seven servers for about twenty minutes on enlistment morning. If it owned them, what share of the year would they be busy?
Twenty minutes is about 0.004% of a year, so the servers were idle almost all the time. Ask for guesses before moving on. The capacity chart in the third step shows the same shape.

Read the two cards. Finance usually approves cloud spending because of how each choice is recorded in the accounts.

CapEx

You own the servers

A large sum is spent up front and written off over several years.

OpEx

You rent by the hour

The cost is a monthly expense, traced to the project that used it.

More detail

What CapEx buys

Servers, a data center and enterprise licenses. The cost is predictable, but you cannot adjust it. You must guess your peak demand years ahead, and a wrong guess is expensive in either direction.

What OpEx buys

Computing time, storage and software subscriptions (SaaS). The starting cost is low and capacity can change, but charges continue every hour. A forgotten test environment is billed every month until someone notices.

The thin line is a year of enlistment demand. Drag the capacity slider and watch the two mistakes: capacity you paid for and did not use, and demand that was turned away. Then switch to renting and compare.

Yearly spend compared with renting
—
Paid for, unused
—
Demand turned away
—
How do you buy capacity?
More detail

Reading the chart

The area between the demand line and the capacity line is either capacity you paid for and did not use, or demand that was turned away. A low capacity setting turns demand away, and a high setting pays for capacity that sits idle.

Renting costs more per unit, but you pay only for what you use. The units in the chart are illustrative.

Total cost of ownership (TCO) is the full cost of a system, beyond its purchase price. Three of its six items follow.

Acquisition

Purchase price, taxes, shipping and installation.

Operating

Power, cooling, bandwidth and licenses, charged every hour whether or not the system is used.

You can now compare buying and renting with more than the purchase price.

More detail

The other three items

Maintenance & support

Servicing, repairs, vendor support contracts, and the software updates (patches) that someone must install, often on a weekend.

Discussion question

How might a startup benefit differently from OpEx than a large enterprise would?

Instructor notes Allow about five minutes for the discussion question. Push students past "it is cheaper", because for a large enterprise with steady load, renting is often more expensive. Useful angles: who can afford to be wrong about their capacity guess, who already owns a data center they have not finished depreciating, and who needs to survive long enough to have a capacity problem at all.